Too many days billed: the Ministry's High Volume Billing letters

This week the Ministry of Health began sending Ontario physicians High Volume Billing letters. The trigger is the number of days a physician billed in a year compared with peers. Dr. A, a family physician on APEX, received one. This article analyzes Dr. A's own billing record, week by week and month by month, to show the pattern behind the letter.

Dr. A billed 311 of 357 days, 87%, with only 46 days off in 51 weeks; the APEX median physician billed 223 days. A calendar shows 50 days in a row without a day off, from March 7 to April 25, 2026
Bar chart of claims a day billed. Over the last 3 months, July 29 to October 27, 2026, Dr. A averaged 52.4 claims a day billed: 3,881 claims in 74 days. Over the last 6 months, April 29 to October 27, it was 47.1: 7,438 claims in 158 days. The APEX median was 30.3 in both

On the days Dr. A billed, they submitted 52.4 claims a day over the last 3 months and 47.1 over the last 6 months. The median family physician on APEX submitted 30.3. Over 3 months Dr. A was above 95% of family physicians on APEX, and over 6 months above 90%.

The Ministry's High Volume Billing letter

Here is the letter Dr. A received. The behaviour it flags, in the letter's words, is a "high number of days worked in a single year", compared with physicians with similar practice profiles. The Ministry sees this through billing, so this article counts days billed.

The Ministry of Health's letter, RE: High Volume Billings. It says Dr. A's billing patterns are higher than those of physicians with similar practice profiles, and flags one anomalous behaviour: a high number of days worked in a single year
The High Volume Billing letter Dr. A received from the Ministry.
  • What it points to: the payment rules in the Health Insurance Act, Regulation 552 and the Schedule of Benefits.
  • What it admits: billing data alone may not capture a physician's circumstances, and there may be legitimate explanations.
  • What it stresses: you are responsible for every claim under your billing number, even when someone else submits it for you.
  • What it doesn't ask: no repayment and no reply is required.
  • What comes next: the Ministry keeps monitoring and may review further if the pattern continues.

OMA's response

The Ontario Medical Association's CEO wrote to members the same week. This is the update as members received it.

OMA News, Update from the CEO. The OMA says it is deeply concerned about the Ministry's letters identifying physicians as having high volume billings, is seeking answers from the government, and that physicians are not required to reply
OMA News · Update from the CEO, as sent to members.

The OMA said it is deeply concerned about the letters and is seeking answers from the government: how physicians were selected, what criteria were used and what the Ministry wants to achieve.

The OMA said that for physicians working hard for their patients and communities, letters that "cast suspicion on that dedication are morally injurious."

How we analyzed Dr. A's record

We read every line of Dr. A's OHIP remittance advice (RA), the payment record OHIP sends each month, by service date for October 2025 to September 2026.

  • A day billed is a service date with at least one paid service.
  • Premiums and tracking codes such as Q012A and Q200A don't count as a day on their own.
  • Reversals (explanatory code 55) cancel the line they reverse.
  • Weeks run Monday to Sunday: 51 full weeks, October 6, 2025 to September 27, 2026.
  • A claim is one OHIP claim number on the RA. Reversal lines don't count. Claims a day use the last 3 and 6 months, to October 27, 2026, with the same windows as Claim Analysis.

Claims rejected outright never reach the RA, so they aren't counted.

Dr. A's days billed, every week

Bar chart of days billed in each of 51 weeks. 19 weeks are 7 days, 25 are 6 days, and a run of 50 days without a day off spans March and April 2026
Most of Dr. A's weeks were 6 or 7 days. The dashed lines are the APEX median and top 10%.
  • October to June: seven-day weeks were routine. From March 7 to April 25, 2026, there was no day off at all.
  • From July: the pattern settled at six days, with Sundays off nearly every week.
  • Breaks were short: Thanksgiving Monday, Christmas and New Year's, nine days in late February and early March, Victoria Day and the August Civic Holiday.
  • Weekends and holidays: 71 of 102 weekend days billed, plus Family Day, Good Friday, Canada Day and Labour Day.

Dr. A compared with other physicians

We compared Dr. A with the 170 physicians on APEX who billed in at least 10 of the 12 months, over the same 51 weeks. Dr. A had the 5th most days billed of the 170. Only 9 billed 300 days or more.

Measure (51 weeks)Dr. AAPEX medianAPEX top 10%
Days billed311223283 or more
Days a week, on average6.14.65.7 or more
Seven-day weeks19110 or more
Weekend days billed713568 or more

On every measure Dr. A sits above the top 10% of APEX physicians. A peer comparison like this is the kind that produces a High Volume Billing letter.

Dr. A's billing submitted, every month

Over the 12 months Dr. A submitted $1,099,922 to OHIP and was paid $1,075,430.

Bar chart of billing submitted each month, from $62k in March 2026 to $108k in September 2026, with days billed below each bar. The four 29-day months are not the highest billing months
The months with the most days billed were not the months with the most billing.

Conclusion: what likely triggers the letter

The Ministry hasn't published how it picks physicians for these letters, and the OMA is asking. From Dr. A's record, our estimate is that the trigger is days billed alone.

How much a physician bills each day doesn't appear to be part of the trigger. The letter's only flag is the number of days. It says nothing about Dr. A's 52 claims a day, even though that's more than most family physicians on APEX bill. This is an estimate from one physician's record, not a published Ministry rule.

If you received a letter

  1. Don't panic and don't rush a reply. No reply is required, and the OMA is following up on members' behalf.
  2. Tell the OMA at info@oma.org that you received one.
  3. Look at your own pattern: days billed a week, weekend and holiday days, and runs without a day off.
  4. Check that your records support each day billed, especially weekends, holidays and after-hours premiums.
  5. Get advice before you change how you practise or write to the Ministry.

How APEX can help

APEX already reads your remittance advice. Claim Analysis (in Manage Claims) shows your days worked over the last 3, 6 or 12 months among every family physician on APEX, with days a week, the longest run without a day off, weekends and holidays, and patients a day. Each figure is marked Normal, Warning or Needs attention.

Claim Analysis Days worked chart, last 12 months: 204 family physicians on APEX from lowest to highest by percentile. An example physician who worked 295 of 365 days sits at percentile 93%, marked Needs attention, just under the 85% line at about 310 days. The APEX average is 201 days
Claim Analysis, Days worked over the last 12 months. The navy dot is an example physician; every other dot is a family physician on APEX, without names.

Many physicians would rather not go through an audit at all, even when every day they billed can be justified. APEX is here to help you avoid being noticed by the Ministry in the first place.

Sources: Ontario Medical Association, Update from the CEO to members (November 2026); Rosen Sunshine LLP, When working too much gets you flagged by OHIP; Auditor General of Ontario, Oversight of Physician Billing (2025). Physician data: Dr. A's APEX remittance advice (name and billing number removed), services October 1, 2025 to October 27, 2026.

APEX offers every physician or group a unique, transparent overview over their billing records.