Too many A003A: a Ministry audit of general assessment billing
The Ministry of Health audited Dr. B, a family physician on APEX, for billing too many A003A general assessments. Unlike the High Volume Billing letters, which flag how many days a physician bills, this audit is about one code and whether each visit met what the Schedule of Benefits requires of it. This article analyzes Dr. B's own billing record to show the pattern behind the audit, and how other family physicians compare.
From November 2025 to May 2026, Dr. B billed 4,502 A003A over 174 days billed: 25.9 a day, the most of the 135 family physicians on APEX with 100 or more days billed. A003A was 46% of everything Dr. B billed. For the median family physician it was 9%.
What A003A requires
A003A is the family practice general assessment, the most thorough assessment in the Schedule. It pays $95.60, more than twice an A007A intermediate assessment ($44.55).
- A full history: the presenting complaint, family history, past medical history, social history, and a functional inquiry into all body parts and systems.
- A full examination: of all body parts and systems. Only a breast, genital or rectal exam may be left out, when it isn't medically indicated or the patient refuses.
- Not in the patient's home, and not by phone or video.
- One per patient per physician every 12 months. A second in 12 months is allowed only when the patient comes back with a clearly different, unrelated diagnosis, or for a hospital admission assessment at least 90 days after the last one.
- Over the limit, OHIP pays a lesser fee: usually A004A general re-assessment ($39.35).
A visit for one or two problems, with an exam of the affected systems, is an A007A intermediate assessment. Billing it as A003A is the pattern a Ministry audit looks for.
Why this audit is different
The OMA called the High Volume Billing letters a profession-wide concern, because they flagged physicians for working many days. Audits of how a single code is billed haven't drawn that response. Checking claims against what the Schedule requires is the Ministry's routine work, and the Auditor General's 2025 report looked at how well the Ministry finds and reviews inappropriate billing.
How we analyzed Dr. B's record
We read every line of Dr. B's OHIP remittance advice (RA), the payment record OHIP sends each month, by service date.
- The main window is November 1, 2025 to May 31, 2026, the seven months before Dr. B's billing changed.
- A day billed is a service date with at least one paid service. Premiums and tracking codes (Q and E codes) don't count as a service.
- Reversals (explanatory code 55) cancel the line they reverse.
- A repeat is an A003A for a patient who already had an A003A from Dr. B in the 365 days before.
- Cut by OHIP means a claim submitted at the A003A fee that the RA shows paid as A004A (explanatory code C2, allowed at re-assessment fee) or A007A (code V8, paid at a lower fee as per OHIP policy).
- Peers are the 135 family physicians on APEX (specialty 00) with 100 or more days billed in the same seven months.
Claims rejected outright never reach the RA, so they aren't counted.
Dr. B's A003A, every month
- November to May: A003A was 37% to 55% of Dr. B's services every month. December was the peak: 876 A003A, 55% of services.
- Highest 30 days: 55.7% of services from December 10, 2025 to January 8, 2026, and 37 A003A a day from December 5 to January 3.
- Busiest days: up to 69 A003A in a single day, and 28 days with 40 or more.
- From June 2026: A003A dropped to about 3% of services and A007A rose from about 400 to about 1,100 a month. Dr. B billed as many services as before.
Repeat A003A and OHIP's own cuts
- 871 repeats: a second A003A for the same patient within 12 months. That's allowed only for a clearly different diagnosis. 488 came within 30 days of the first, and the median gap was 22 days.
- 916 cut by OHIP: OHIP's payment system already paid 666 at the A004A re-assessment fee and 250 at the A007A fee. Cuts like these on the RA are a signal before any audit.
- New patients: 73% of the A003A were for patients Dr. B hadn't billed for in the previous 12 months.
- Not rostered: 4,497 of the 4,502 were for patients not rostered to Dr. B. Dr. B is in an FHO, where an A003A for a rostered patient is covered by capitation. For a patient who isn't rostered it pays the full fee.
Dr. B compared with other physicians
| Measure (Nov 2025 – May 2026) | Dr. B | APEX median | APEX top 10% |
|---|---|---|---|
| A003A a day billed | 25.9 | 4.1 | 11.6 or more |
| A003A share of all services | 46% | 9% | 27% or more |
| Repeat A003A within 12 months | 871 | 28 | 231 or more |
| Repeat A003A within 30 days | 488 | 4 | 64 or more |
| A003A cut by OHIP to a lower fee | 916 | 1 | 50 or more |
| Days billed | 174 | 140 | 174 or more |
Dr. B was first of 135 on A003A a day billed and second on the A003A share of services, on repeats and on OHIP's cuts. Their days billed were high but not unusual.
Dr. B isn't alone. Over the same seven months, 4 other family physicians on APEX billed 17 or more A003A a day billed, 11 others billed A003A as 30% or more of their services, and 7 others had more than 100 claims cut by OHIP from A003A to a lower fee.
What's at stake
From November 2025 to May 2026, OHIP paid Dr. B $403,266 for A003A. Paid at the A007A fee, the same number of visits would have come to about $180,500, a difference of about $222,700 in seven months.
After the switch to A007A in June, Dr. B billed slightly more services a month than in April and May, but was paid about 30% less a month. If an audit finds that visits didn't meet the A003A requirements, it can ask for the difference back.
Conclusion: what likely triggers the audit
The Ministry doesn't publish how it picks physicians to audit. From Dr. B's record, our estimate is that the trigger is how often A003A is billed compared with other family physicians.
These lines are estimates from one physician's record, not a published Ministry rule. Billing above them doesn't mean a claim was wrong, and billing below them doesn't make a visit a general assessment.
When a high A003A count is justified
A high number of A003A isn't wrong on its own. Each A003A is justified when the encounter note in the EMR shows every element the Schedule requires. An audit is decided on those notes, not on the count.
- The history of the presenting complaint.
- Family, past medical and social history.
- A functional inquiry into all body parts and systems.
- An examination of all body parts and systems, with the reason when a breast, genital or rectal exam wasn't medically indicated or was refused.
- In person, at a place other than the patient's home.
- For a second A003A within 12 months: the clearly different, unrelated diagnosis, or that it was a hospital admission assessment 90 or more days after the last one.
A practice that sees many new or unattached patients can bill many A003A for good reason, as long as each note shows the full assessment. An EMR template helps only when it's filled in for that patient at that visit. A note copied forward, or a template left with default or blank fields, doesn't show the service was done.
What every physician should check
- Your A003A share. Most family physicians on APEX bill A003A for under 10% of their services. Over 30% needs a reason you can explain.
- Repeats within 12 months. A second A003A for the same patient needs a clearly different diagnosis. A third is never paid as A003A.
- C2 and V8 on your RA. Each is OHIP paying your A003A at a lower fee. Many of them mean the pattern is already visible.
- Your charts. Each A003A note should show the full history, the functional inquiry into all systems and the exam of all systems.
- New and walk-in patients. A first visit isn't automatically a general assessment. If the visit was for one problem, it's an A007A.
- If you're audited, read what the letter asks for and get legal advice before you reply. Don't change past claims on your own.
How APEX can help
APEX already reads your remittance advice. Claim Analysis (in Manage Claims) shows your A003A as a share of all your services and as a count a day billed, next to the APEX average for family physicians, over the last 3 or 6 months.
The A003A card also carries an Audit reference: Dr. B's level in their highest 3 and 6 months. At or above it, the card is marked Needs attention. From 80% of it, it's marked Warning.
Claim Analysis compares you with other physicians on APEX as a percentile and never shows another physician's own figures.
Sources: Ontario Schedule of Benefits for Physician Services, General Preamble (general assessment) and Family Practice listings (A003, A004, A007); Ministry of Health, remittance advice explanatory codes (C2, V8); Auditor General of Ontario, Oversight of Physician Billing (2025). Physician data: Dr. B's APEX remittance advice (name and billing number removed), services October 1, 2025 to October 27, 2026; peers: 135 family physicians on APEX, November 1, 2025 to May 31, 2026.
APEX offers every physician or group a unique, transparent overview over their billing records.