Too many days billed: followup
Last week we analyzed the record of Dr. A, a family physician who received the Ministry's High Volume Billing letter. Since then, three more family physicians on APEX told us they received the same letter. With four records, we can test what the letters have in common.
- 85% of days billed: the line, about 310 of 365
- 319+ days billed in 12 months, all four letters
- 16 to 60 patients a day: volume varies
- 243 APEX median days billed
The four records
- Dr. C · FHG 335 days 30 days off. 60 patients a day. 67 days in a row without a day off.
- Dr. D · FHO 331 days 34 days off. 16 patients a day. 54 days in a row without a day off.
- Dr. A · FHG 319 days 46 days off. 42 patients a day. 50 days in a row without a day off.
- Dr. E · FHO 319 days 46 days off. 20 patients a day. 51 days in a row without a day off.
Patient volume isn't part of it
Dr. D sees about 16 patients a day, fewer than most family physicians on APEX. Dr. C sees 60, more than almost all of them. Both received the same letter. Many physicians see more patients a day than Dr. A or Dr. E and received no letter, because they billed fewer days.
Testing other rules
We tried each rule that catches all four letters and counted how many other physicians on APEX it would also flag. Fewer is a better fit.
- Days billed fits best. Set at the lowest of the four letters, it flags only 3 more physicians.
- A one-claim day counts. Dr. E had 27 days with only one or two services. If those days didn't count, Dr. E would drop to 305 days and 6 other physicians would clear the same bar.
- Runs, seven-day weeks and weekends catch all four as well, but each also flags more physicians who reported no letter.
- Patients or services a day would flag more than 100 physicians.
Where the line sits
All four letters billed at least 319 days, 87% of the year. We put the line at 85% of days, about 310 of 365: a round share that every letter clears, and about six days a week, every week of the year.
Six other physicians on APEX also billed 85% of days or more. We don't know whether they received a letter.
What this analysis can't see
- The Ministry's exact year. The letter says "a single year" without dates. We used each physician's busiest 12 months between June 2025 and October 2026. A fiscal year, April to March, could rank physicians differently.
- Records before mid-2025. APEX's records for most physicians start in summer or fall 2025. One of the six physicians above the line started billing in September 2025, so they had no full fiscal year.
- Billing APEX doesn't receive. Claims under another billing number or group, and claims rejected outright, aren't counted.
- The exact cutoff. Fitted to the four letters alone, the line falls between 315 and 319 days. 85% sits just below that.
- Peers. The Ministry compares physicians with "similar practice profiles". It hasn't said how it groups them.
How we counted
- A day billed is a service date with at least one paid service on the remittance advice (RA).
- Premiums and tracking codes such as Q012A and Q200A don't count as a day on their own.
- Reversals (explanatory code 55) cancel the line they reverse.
- Busiest 12 months is the run of 365 days with the most days billed. Only physicians with a full year of RA are compared: 142 on APEX.
- Patients a day counts distinct patients with a paid service, on days billed.
What changed from our first estimate
Our first article estimated the trigger from Dr. A alone: billing 87% of days, or a run of about 50 days with no day off.
- A share of days holds. All four billed 87% or more of their busiest 12 months. With four records, we put the line at 85%.
- The 50-day run fits worse. All four had one, but so did 6 other physicians, including 3 who billed under 85% of days and reported no letter.
- Dr. A's count: our first article counted 311 days over 51 weeks from October. Dr. A's busiest 12 months, September 2025 to September 2026, held 319.
If you're near the line
- Count your days billed in the last 12 months. About 300 puts you in the top 10% on APEX. The line is 85% of days, about 310.
- Count your days off. 55 or fewer in a year puts you at 85% or more.
- Remember that one claim makes a day. A single paid service on a day off, such as one virtual visit, adds a day billed.
- Don't rush a reply. No reply is required. The OMA is following up and asks members who got a letter to tell it at info@oma.org.
How APEX can help
Claim Analysis in Manage Claims shows your days worked over the last 3, 6 or 12 months among every family physician on APEX. Over the last 12 months, Warning starts at about 254 days (top 25%) and Needs attention at about 289 (top 10%), both before the 85% line.
Many physicians would rather not go through an audit at all, even when every day they billed can be justified. APEX is here to help you avoid being noticed by the Ministry in the first place.
Sources: Ministry of Health, High Volume Billings letter (November 2026); Ontario Medical Association, Update from the CEO to members (November 2026). Physician data: APEX remittance advice for Dr. A, Dr. C, Dr. D and Dr. E (names and billing numbers removed) and 142 physicians on APEX with a full year of RA, services June 2025 to October 2026.
APEX offers every physician or group a unique, transparent overview over their billing records.